Govt cannot refuse NOC to employee on technical grounds: CAT



Government cannot refuse to give no objection certificate (NOC) to an employee on "vexatious technical grounds" if no public interest was involved, the Central Administrative Tribunal has said.

"Denial to grant NOC is not sustainable as it is not the case of Ministry of Defence that there is a shortage of officers and the applicant's departure would be greatly inconvenient...Neither public interest is pleaded nor could it be established," a bench of CAT, comprising Chairman V K Bali and Vice Chairman L K Joshi, said.

The tribunal passed the order on a plea filed by Satyam, Assistant Medical Officer working with the Ordnance Factory Hospital, which had rejected her application seeking permission to appear in an interview for the post of Insurance Medical Officer in Employees State Insurance Corporation (ESIC).

The Ministry had rejected Satyam's request on the ground that the last date of submission of application was over.

"The only claim of the Ministry is that the application was not submitted before the expiry of time for its submission to ESIC. This is merely a vexatious technical objection," the tribunal said.

Source:PTI

Comments

amit gulia said…
i wanna ask can the department can deny NOC to a govt. servant on the basis of grade pay e. g. if someone's grade pay is rs. 6600 and wanna join a job having rs 5400 grade pay, especially when the CAT has given this ruling?? can somebody enlighten ??
Rajesh said…
can any one provide the judgement number or case number of the above CAT orders.. or the individual's contact information so that more details can be sort out..Thanks.
Rajesh Kumar
amit gulia said…
can anybody give the case number or other relevant information about this case???
Vijay Sadia said…
whats the case no. of cat? and what is the rules for NOC? should we have to appear in exam through proper channel? and how to follow proper channel in online application??
Vijay Sadia said…
whats the rule for NOC? what is the proper channel in online applicatio? can i get NOC if i dont have apply through proper channel?
Anonymous said…
can a person get noc for the same grade pay also. and the application for NOC should be submitted within the closing date of application.one more question is if some one wants to apply for outside employment other than upsc or ssc it should be forwarded through proper channel.
my email. sumit_singh79@rediffmail.com



















_
Anonymous said…
Please provide the judgement no. and date of judgement. I could not find the same in the CAT website http://cgat.gov.in/.

Thanks
Anonymous said…
Please provide the details i.e. no. and date of the judgement.
poonam said…
hello admin,
can u tell me the decision no. or the case no. of this case of Mr. Satyam.... coz' i m also in same situation.
Anonymous said…
Sir ,,i m also looking for the answer ...if u have received any so far ,plz provide me on my email id mohitsingh36@yahoo.com
Anonymous said…
Ordnance factories are denying permission to their employees for appearing in upsc exam and are communicating to upsc that their employees candidature be cancelled citing public interest. what can be done ?
Unknown said…
Sir....i want to apply in state govt via taking NOC, but my office demanding hardcopy of the advertisement....Before when i have taken NOC at that time they not demanded but now demanding...!!!
is department demanding the hardcopy ? if yes then before they have issued me NOC without hardcopy..

please all of us give me ruling number and reply me at my mail id: prajapati3689@gmail.com
Unknown said…
Sir mai ssc interview me job ke bare me nahi bola par jab mujhe dept se attestation form aaya to mai usme mention kar diya hai previous job ke bare me jo psu me tha maine uske sath relieve order laga diya hai kya dept hame join karye ga ya ssc ko inform nahi karne se wo displinary me aaye ga please clarify
Unknown said…
Post facto application for noc for higher studies under distance mode by a govt employee given during the course of study. Is it to be considered by the state govt department. plz giv any reference

Popular posts from this blog

Central Government Office Holiday List 2023 - DoPT Order PDF Download

7th CPC Pay Fixation on Promotion/MACP Calculator with Matrix Table

Revised Pay Scale from 1.7.2017 for Karnataka Govt Employees